logo
OncTalk, LLC
OncTalk has moved to GRACE!.
Please migrate over and enjoy the new and
improved OncTalk through GRACE.
       
Add to Google

Add to My Yahoo!

Subscribe with Bloglines


"As of April 30, 2008, all content from OncTalk will remain browsable and searchable, but no further content is being added to the post section or discussion forums. Post content has been moved to the website for GRACE (www.cancergrace.org). Please visit GRACE to provide your comments to posts and to initiate threads or add to the discussions in the forums on the GRACE site."

 

November 6, 2007


Email This Post
Print This Post

Calcitriol (Vitamin D Analog) Study Halted in Prostate Cancer

  This doesn’t directly relate to lung cancer, but in a prior post I described a trial of the vitamin D analog calcitriol (Asentar) with taxotere for treating advanced NSCLC.  Although it has been very unclear whether there might be any future for this agent in lung cancer, I and many others were pretty impressed by the results of a randomized phase II trial for metastatic prostate cancer, called ASCENT, with 250 patients who were randomized to taxotere and prednisone with or without calcitriol.  This study actually showed an improvement in overall survival in the recipients of calcitriol with chemo, but it wasn’t a huge trial.  A larger phase III randomized study with the same design (called ASCENT-2, cleverly enough) has been ongoing in prostate cancer.   Presumably, if this one came out as well,  it would look good for it to be approved by FDA.

   While we don’t have any real results yet, we know from a press release that the trial was stopped early due to an unexpected excess of deaths on the arm that received calcitriol with chemo.  This led the Data Safety Monitoring Board to close the trial.  This doesn’t have any immediate implications for lung cancer, except that now I’d really doubt we’ll see the concept I described in my post followed with a larger study in lung cancer.  And it’s another example of how an early small trial can look really promising, but the new treatment not only be of no significant benefit but also potentially be harmful.  I haven’t been recommending high dose vitamin D for my patients, but it’s a cautionary point that there might be detrimental effects from high doses of certain vitamins (potentially from the interaction with chemo but wouldn’t occur without concurrent chemo).  I don’t have any more details, but I’ll let you know if we learn more.



posted by Dr. West @ 2:38 pm link to this post

2 Responses to “Calcitriol (Vitamin D Analog) Study Halted in Prostate Cancer”

  1. 1
    betty r. Says:

    Dr. West,

    What do you consider “high dose” vitamin D? My mom is currently getting Taxotere every 3 weeks and also takes Rocaltrol (1mcg/day) with calcium for hypoparathyroidism/hypocalcemia. Is that a dose to worry about?

    Thanks,
    Betty

  2. 2
    Dr. West Says:

    Betty
    The vitamin D/calcitriol dose used in these trials were considerably higher, and they weren’t given as a treatment for hypoparathyroidism. I can’t know for sure, since we really don’t know why people getting high dose vitamin D did worse, but I would say that there’s a huge difference between getting necessary treatment for a particular problem, and taking as high doses as can be safely tolerated to see if it has effects on the cancer itself. Without knowing for sure, I’d consider this to be a totally different situation from your mother’s.

    -Dr. West

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

top of page Browse Complete Archives
Email This Post
Print This Post
About the Author:
Howard (Jack) West, MD
Dr. West serves as the Founder and Managing Member of OncTalk, LLC. He is a medical oncologist and Director of Medical Therapeutics for Thoracic Oncology at the Swedish Cancer Institute in Seattle, Washington.
Bio | C.V. | Contact



POLLS

Do you prefer to see generic names or trade names for drugs in our posts and comments?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Disclaimer: The information provided at OncTalk is for informational purposes only. Howard West, MD is not providing medical advice, diagnosis or treatment and cannot replace the medical advice of your doctor or health care provider. (Full Disclaimer)
© 2006-07 OncTalk LLC. All rights reserved. Contact Webmaster




Disclaimer: The information provided at OncTalk is for informational purposes only. Howard West, MD is not providing medical advice, diagnosis or treatment and cannot replace the medical advice of your doctor or health care provider.